The tragedy that unfolded in our nation’s capital last week has opened old wounds and raised new questions about who we let through our doors and why.
A video has resurfaced showing Kentucky Representative Andy Barr, now running for the United States Senate, making an impassioned case for bringing Afghan nationals into America through special visa programs. The timing could not be more politically fraught. Just days ago, an Afghan national allegedly murdered a young National Guard member in Washington, DC, in what authorities describe as a targeted attack.
In the clip, Barr makes his position crystal clear. “We have failed in our obligation to help many of these Afghans who risked their lives and in many cases, died for the cause of their own country in assistance to the United States,” he stated. “We owe them to help them get into our country with these visas, and the p1 and p2 visas as well.”
The congressman went further, arguing that abandoning Afghan allies would damage American credibility worldwide. “I voted for these special immigrant visas because it would send a terrible message to our allies around the world that we’re going to abandon you if you help us in your time of need,” Barr said.
Now comes the hard part of that equation. On November 26, twenty-year-old Sarah Beckstrom was shot and killed while serving her country as a member of the West Virginia National Guard. Her fellow guardsman, Andrew Wolfe, was critically wounded. The alleged shooter, twenty-nine-year-old Rahmanullah Lakanwal, is an Afghan national who authorities confirm worked with the CIA in Afghanistan.
According to officials, Lakanwal was admitted under President Biden’s Operation Allies Welcome program but was later in the country unlawfully. He reportedly traveled across the country to carry out this attack, shouting “Allahu Akbar” before seizing a guard’s weapon and continuing his assault.
This is where theory meets reality on the streets of America.
The attack has sparked renewed scrutiny of the refugee and visa policies implemented during the chaotic Afghanistan withdrawal. Inspector general reports and whistleblower accounts have previously highlighted significant security concerns involving individuals admitted through Operation Allies Welcome. The vetting procedures, or lack thereof, have become a focal point of this examination.
The fundamental question facing policymakers like Barr is not simple. America has long prided itself on keeping promises to those who stand with us in dangerous places. The men and women who risked everything to assist American forces in Afghanistan did so with the understanding that we would not leave them behind. That is the American way, and it matters.
But it also matters that we protect Americans at home. When vetting processes fail, when individuals slip through the cracks, when political expedience trumps security protocols, innocent Americans pay the price. Sarah Beckstrom paid with her life.
Representative Barr now faces voters who will weigh his position against this tragic outcome. The debate over Afghan special visas represents a broader tension in American foreign policy between honoring commitments abroad and ensuring security at home. There are no easy answers, but the questions deserve honest examination as Kentucky voters head to the polls.
Related: Hegseth Defends Lethal Strikes Against Cartel Operations as Lawful Military Action
