There are moments in American politics when the rubber meets the road, when all the talk and posturing must give way to hard choices. For Senate Republicans, that moment has arrived.
The question before them is as old as it is urgent: Do you preserve a procedural tradition that your opponents will almost certainly abolish the moment they regain power, or do you act now while you have the chance to deliver for the millions of Americans who sent you to Washington with a clear mandate?
Make no mistake about it, the Republican Party has spent the better part of two decades wandering in the wilderness of its own making. While claiming the mantle of conservatism, too many establishment figures became virtually indistinguishable from their Democratic counterparts. The result speaks for itself in numbers that would make any accountant wince: $38 trillion in national debt with precious little to show for it.
President Trump changed that calculus. He brought to Washington a new breed of lawmaker, men and women who understand they were sent to the nation’s capital to fight for Main Street, not to become comfortable fixtures of the Swamp. These America First representatives learned a valuable lesson from Trump: you do not win political battles by playing it safe. You win by advancing the ball downfield.
Now comes the hard part. Congressional Republicans must deliver on the agenda that 77 million Americans voted for in November 2024. But delivery requires more than good intentions and stirring speeches. It requires strategic thinking and, yes, a willingness to make tough calls.
The filibuster sits at the center of this debate, and it deserves a clear-eyed examination free from sentimentality. This Senate tradition, which began in the 1800s as a mechanism for extended debate, has morphed into something its creators never envisioned. Originally, debate continued until a simple majority voted to end it. That changed in 1917 with the Cloture Rule, requiring a two-thirds vote. By the 1970s, the threshold dropped to 60 votes, where it remains today.
What was once a tool for meaningful debate has become a weapon that amplifies the power of individual senators far beyond what the Founders intended. Some lawmakers cling to it because, frankly, it enhances their personal influence. But the American people did not send representatives to Washington to accumulate personal power. They sent them to get things done.
The political reality is stark. Democrats came within two votes of eliminating the filibuster during their last stint in power. Only former Senators Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema stood in the way. Does anyone seriously believe that firewall will hold next time? The moment Democrats regain Senate control, the filibuster will likely vanish faster than morning dew in August. And with it will come a flood of radical legislation: court packing, border destruction, electric vehicle mandates, and extreme abortion policies.
Recent events underscore the danger of inaction. Democrats recently wielded the filibuster to shut down the government for 43 days, holding hostage the paychecks of troops, veterans, law enforcement officers, and air traffic controllers. Their message could not be clearer: they would rather harm American servicemembers than allow President Trump to advance his agenda.
This is the new normal Republicans must prepare for. Democrats have shown their hand. They will use every procedural tool at their disposal to obstruct, delay, and derail the America First movement.
The question facing Senate Republicans is not whether the filibuster is a noble tradition. The question is whether they have the courage to act decisively while they still can, or whether they will cling to a procedural security blanket that offers only the illusion of protection. President Trump has his work cut out for him digging America out of the hole created over the past four years. Republicans owe it to the American people to give him the tools to succeed.
Related: Supreme Court Delays Decision on Trump’s Authority to Fire Copyright Office Chief
